Showing posts with label MMO. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MMO. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 30, 2025

TennoCon, Travel, and Online life

I'm not sure where this one is going. My wife and I just got back last week from TennoCon 2025 ... TennoCon 10 and the trip was an absolute blast as it has been since we started going in 2018. (Note- 2020-2022 there was no physical convention as it was digital only due to the Pandemic but they still had an event even if only online) ... For those that don't know TennoCon is the annual convention hosted by Digital Extremes in their home town of London, Ontario for their game Warframe (Which I've talked about before) and now for their new game in development, Soulframe. It is a celebration, not just of the game, but of the community and the development team, where they give talks about the making of the game(s), and about the plans for the future of the game(s).

But it's also more than that, because the community that surrounds the game is amazing, great creators and amazing players that all share a common bond in Warframe. 2024 saw them expand the convention to two days, Friday and Saturday (Prior to that it was only a Saturday event), with registration, early Merch access and a party on Friday night before the main convention on Saturday. This year was much the same, but they expanded Friday a bit to include some of the autograph times, the Cosplay Contest (And some absolutely amazing entries this year I might add), and this year was a full blown, first ever, TennoCONcert. (The full TennoCon Cosplay, Concert and Panels is up on YouTube at LINK)

That's the OFFICIAL stuff ... but that's only a part of what TennoCon means ... Meeting friends from around the world that you only get to spend time with at the convention. Hanging out and talking about the reveals and announcements in the park Sunday afternoon after the Con is officially over and the Devs and Voice talent coming to hang out and chat with the players and fans. Many of us come into town early and leave late, for me this year it was 8 vacation days from work, time to relax, and see and hang out with friends that I hadn't seen since 2024. If you play warframe go to a TennoCon the energy there is amazing and invigorating ... if you don't play Warframe ... Have you tried Warframe? It's Free to Play on all platforms (except Android currently ... so PC, XBox, PS, Switch, and iOS) with cross-play and cross-save now.

Don't get me wrong, TennoCon has it's trials. Traveling is expensive and, since it's an international trip that creates it's own headaches, not to mention hotel, eating out, etc. The last few years have also had some trials with ticket sales ... namely they sell out FAST. London, ON isn't a huge city the convention center is good, but it can only fit so many people. This has a lot of fans calling to move to a larger venue such as Toronto. That bring another set of logistic issues, the London Convention Center has an advantage in that it is quite literally across the street from the Digital Extremes offices. Part of me wants to see them grow the convention further, make it even more of an event, and that will likely NEED a larger space ... They got the stadium this year for the Cosplay contest and Concert ... but unless they make that the main stage for TennoLive on Saturday as well, I'm not sure that it's a practical venue for the Con as a whole. But another part of me doesn't want them to leave London. So many of the traditions of the Convention are tied to local landmarks, restaurants, and, of course, the Sunday hang out at the park.

The announcements this year certainly have my interest, the upcoming expansions, new stories, new characters, and new abilities make the rest of 2025 and into 2026 a bright future. And the Roleplay rules coming in October will give me something to read and consider as well. Warframe is still growing, still innovating and evolving and I'll be very interested to see where it goes....

Had a great time there, and came back and the wife and I were feeling a bit nostalgic so we went back old school, and I mean WAY back ... we went back to EverQuest our first MMO. Just out of curiosity I looked today and Klikhizz, my main character and the character that my blogs were kind of based around, was created on July 9th 2000 ... so he just turned 25 this year. Now we started playing a little before that, we had played on other servers and I believe that Ralit was my first character on Torv. (I don't remember the full spelling, we all just called it Torv and it's since been server merged into Cazic-Thule ... rather fitting actually.) ... But even that was a coincidence ... My wife and I had characters elsewhere, but for one reason or another the server that our characters were on was down when we went to play one night, and, if I remember correctly, Torv was a newer server, having just launched in April 2000 with the release of the Ruins of Kunark expansion, so we went to play over there ... and, ultimately, the rest IS history. Because we found a community there and over the next several years, helped build it.

We played EverQuest solidly until their 8th or 9th expansion ... so Late 2004 or early 2005. I don't remember if we left before or after Dragons of Norrath launched if I'm being honest, and we've played off and on since then. Often coming back for anniversaries or several of the Progression server launches. To be honest I was shocked to realize that it was only 4-5 years that we played solid, it felt like so much more. I still have online friends that I made in that game so long ago, some I've met in real life over the years, some I never have managed. Many I've lost touch with, but still think about, still wonder what ever happened to them, how they're doing. 

Of course we played EQII when it came out, and we enjoyed it. We re-formed the Scales of Pain, or original guild on EQ, and did quite a bit of content in that game, though we didn't play nearly as long and haven't gone back nearly as much. I mentioned before that EQ was, to me at least, the MMO that got most everything right, it was a sandbox and we built a story in it. (For the record, my wife and I did not start the Scales of Pain in EQ, we joined it and made it our family, she was made an officer, and later I was made Guild Leader ... I'm happy to say that the original founders told me later that though I changed the guild drastically they loved what I made it into and thanked me for making it what it became ... since then I have always considered the Scales mine .... of course a little of that is Klik's arrogance and confidence 😜)

I mentioned EQ: Next in earlier rambles here ... the elusive EQIII ... I hope it comes out, and if/when it does I hope that the developers do it right, go back to the original design and make EQ as a modern sandbox ... with a modern unified UI because coming back to EQ ... that UI is ... *shudders*

December 2024 saw EQ launch their 31st expansion "The Outer Brood" ... all expansions up to the 29th (Night of Shadows) is included in their Free-to-play part of the game, and purchasing The Outer Brood includes Laurion's Song, the 30th expansion which raised the level cap to 125. Certain features (such as the better NPC mercenaries, certain AAs, Spell tiers, and the like are put behind membership, of course, but that is to be expected in all honesty, though I DO wish they'd cut back on how often the 'upgrade to member' pop-ups came up during gameplay. Still, the wife and I are playing and enjoying the nostalgia, exploring some things we've never done and remember some things that we have done in the past. Remembering old friends, good times, and frustrating times ... and wondering how in the HECK we managed doing a lot of the things that we did without voice chat ....  

 

Monday, July 6, 2015

A Tale in the Desert

Those that have known me for a while may remember that I wrote about this game a loooong time ago (well a long time ago in computer/game terms at least) on a forum for another game entirely. A Tale in the Desert is a game my wife and I first encountered back in early 2003 when it launched. Since then it's a game that we've returned to several times over the years and as such I've decided that it deserves some attention again.

A Tale in the Desert is a persistent MMO with a focus on social interaction, building and puzzle solving. A Tale in the Desert (ATitD for short) differs from most MMOs in a couple or ways. First there is no combat in the game. There is no 'threat' that your character is trying to overcome (There's a challenge, but I'll get into that more later) and you are not a 'hero' that is some how better than everyone else. Secondly there are NO NPCs* to interact with, you don't go out and get your loot and sell it to the vender for in game coin ... in fact there IS no in game coin either. (* - Note - there can be 'NPCs' but only in that the developers may spawn characters for story reasons, but such characters are being controlled by a Dev or GM at a keyboard, not interacting on their own via AI.) Finally, and probably the biggest thing, is that it is designed to have an ending.

Just because I say that there's no combat in ATitD, don't make the mistake of thinking that there's no conflict. I've seen as much if not more conflict and drama in ATitD than I have in some purely PvP MMOs. ATitD has a lot of competitive tests, and a lot of other issues (Pollution, resource availability, etc.) that can create conflict and drama between people. Additionally, there are player elected positions (Demi-Pharaoh), player proposed and passed laws, and the general social nature of the game that creates plenty of opportunity for debate and ... we'll call them 'heated discussions'.

Of course that plays into and is enhanced by the lack of NPCs in the game. ALL of your interaction is with other players. Now there are certainly things that you can go off and do on your own, but generally speaking one player isn't going to be able to do everything themselves. At some point you're going to need to trade for items that you can't find or make yourself, or need the assistance of other players to get some of those items. In many cases for the various Tests you will need other players in different capacities (to judge your art work, or puzzles, to vote for you or your law, etc.) This isn't to say that dealing with players is always bad, it's not. I have many great memories of group events over the various times that I've played, and I certainly wouldn't have those without the other players.

The biggest difference from most MMOs, however, is really the fact that it is designed to end. There is a point in the game that is meant to trigger the 'end game'. The 'goal' is to promote an Oracle in each of the 7 Schools of Man (Harmony, Body, Worship, Architecture, Art & Music, Leadership, and Thought) and build a monument to each of the 7 Schools before the end date. As part of the monument a new test is designed and 'inscribed' into the monument for future generations.  At the end the server is wiped, changes made to various game systems and mechanics, and a new Tale begins with a new generation of immigrants to the desert lands.

At the time of this writing Tale 6 is drawing to a close and Tale 7 is being discussed and planned as the players start the push to build the 7 monuments and I find myself once more drawn to this social/building sandbox. A little history here, I played at the beginning of Tale 1 in early 2003, came back for the beginning of Tale 3 in mid 2006 and the beginning of Tale 4 in late 2008. You may notice on those dates that they all say 'the beginning of tale x'. Something (in some cases just deciding that I have stuff that needs to get done in real life) has always interrupted my involvement in a telling.

But why do I keep coming back? There's a lot I like about the game. First off, it's a sandbox. While there is the over all goal of the telling (get 7 Oracles and build the 7 Monuments) those are (particularly at the beginning of a telling) insubstantial goals and I can pick and choose my own goals. There's also the social aspect, and tied to it, the political aspect. The introduction of Levels in Tale 3 did kind of bottleneck things early on, but then really became meaningless and did, really, encourage me to try out other things in the game more.

There are also a couple of down sides. First it's not a game that everyone will 'get'. Some people aren't looking for a social/building game as they tend toward a slower more thoughtful pace and some people really do want the faster pace / more immediate gratification of an action game or more traditional MMO. The real down side in ATitD, even for someone like me that loves so many aspects of the game is that it can be a horrendous time sink, particularly early in a telling before the various automated techs are researched. There is so much to do, and since other players are involved in so many ways in this game, your schedule isn't always their first concern.

Tale 6 has gone free to play for the remainder of the telling, so if a social/building MMO sounds interesting, by all means check it out (there's a download link on their website - www.atitd.com) it's kept me coming back for over 12 years. If you have any questions you can shoot me a chat in game (/chat Tahrqa) and I'll get back to you when I can ... one word of advice though ... get a Hand Loom asap ... the Student Loom is a horrible torture device.

Thursday, January 8, 2015

Open Development and Reality

I've mentioned before that for Landmark and EQ:Next (and H1Z1 which goes to early access next week) SOE is using an 'Open Development' style of development.

This means that the developers are very accessible to the community and they are getting their ideas into the communities hands at a much earlier stage of development than has traditionally been the case. They aren't just talking about their ideas with us, they are letting us test the versions at a much earlier stage, listening to our feedback (as well as their own observations) and making adjustments to the game in a way that we can see the process.

I love the idea. I'm very much enjoying being involved in the process, giving feedback and reading their responses to the issues that the players are bringing up. I love the insight that it gives into the process. We get to see their idea, but we also get to see it change and evolve and in the end we have an understanding of WHY they made at least some of the choices that they did.

That said I think they've made a few mistakes with it as well. First is that they made it an every day alpha/beta, meaning that the servers have been up and accessible continually (except for patches) since Alpha started last February. Don't get me wrong, I've played a lot and had a ton of fun on my schedule because of that, but it also meant that there were long periods of time where there was nothing new to test, and with as early as they started there was really nothing to do in game either. 

The result was that for long periods the servers were ghost towns as people stopped playing for very long periods of time. Keeping an eye on the forums and waiting for news of a feature that they were interested in seeing. I think part of this was the result of unforseen delays that meant that some of the systems that they had expected to have out in 2-3 months didn't get out until 8 months down the road. 

In this case I think they would have been better off either shuttering the test servers for a couple weeks a month to get some material together, patch it in, and then bring the servers up for a week or so to let us kick it around. I think that it would have kept people more directly engaged in the process. Conversely they could have waited and built up a larger feature base before opening the doors in the first place, giving us more to play with up front and then pushing things out regularly and fixing issues that came up.

(Additionally I think that they should have had the Alpha phase run longer than it did (Alpha was Feb 1 - March 26 ... so a little under 2 months.) This would have possibly allowed them to bridge the two options that I outlined above by keeping the testing community a little smaller.)

Their other mistake, and in my opinion probably the biggest mistake of the two, is that they haven't wiped data. The result is that people have built up more and more, and become more and more adverse to having that accumulated gear/builds and just the 'stuff' of having played wiped and lost. But the flip side is that as a result, unless people have purposefully done something the 'starting' aspect of the game isn't being tested by most of the testers (yes several, including myself, occasionally go back to using the starter tools, but we still have the accumulated resources and other stuff that we've already gathered, so it's not the same as a NEW player.)

It also means that some of the fixes may or may not be complete. There are areas in the world that are flagged as claimed even though there is no longer a claim there. Trees that can't be harvested. The bugs that caused these things are supposedly fixed, but they still exist in the world so are things being wiped properly now? I can't really tell because I still encounter them occasionally but without keeping a database of where all the ones I find are I can't tell if I'm finding new ones or just ones that I hadn't seen before.

While I understand the desire to let people keep what they earned in game, we aren't here to 'play' we're here to test and make sure things work right. I think that they could have found a balance here with a few regular wipes. Say in the 11 months we've been testing wipe 5 or 6 times that gives us 6 week to 8 weeks of testing before resetting. Again I think it would have kept people a little more engaged and it would have allowed us to reset the worlds and make sure that things that were supposed to be fixed were definitely cleaned up. (Keep in mind that there was a wipe between Alpha and Beta, and a wipe early in Alpha because of a database issue, but there hasn't been any since Closed Beta kicked off in March 2014).

I think that SOE has learned a bit from their mistakes with the Landmark Beta. I suspect (I don't have any direct knowledge of this just hunch and theory) that this is why the H1Z1 early access went from being in 2-6 weeks, to starting about 7 months later as I think that they opted to wait and get more systems into the game and ready for testing before opening the flood gates.

Not everyone gets the system and you'll always end up with those 'testers' that are there to play the game and not there to test and give feedback. So there's still a good bit of 'noise' and people that complain about systems 'not making sense' because the system is only partially implemented, or is in the midst of a revamp. While I think that SOE may be seeing a little more of that than normal because they're getting stuff to the testers earlier, any development method is going to have those issues at some stage.

In the end I'm hoping that some players are paying attention and learning something about the development process involved in these types of games. I'm pretty sure that other developers are taking notice and will be looking to see how Landmark / Next do in the end. If those projects are successful because of player/community involvement in the process then I really think that we will likely see more of this type of development cycle.

Wednesday, January 7, 2015

Landmark – Thoughts on Beta


Keep in mind that these are still ramblings about a game that is in closed beta. It is not in its final state and things are constantly changing. SOE is going through what they’re calling an ‘open development’ process where they are giving players very early access to things in order to get feedback and make adjustments. Two quick things about this now, and I’ll probably do an article on this aspect of things specifically later. First it’s great, the accessibility of the team and the communication is tremendous. Also it gives a lot of insight into the development process on a project like this. The downside, however, is that a lot of the ‘testers’ involved don’t understand what they’re in the middle of. Many of them seem to think that SOE can just wave a wand and make a change, or have the new revision live.

That aside, there are still some things to talk about re: Landmark The Game. The team pushed out a huge update just before the holidays last month. Adding a lot of features that had been in the works for the better part of the year … in particular underworld layers and NPC monsters (combat had been in for a while, but was strictly PvP on designated player claims.) They also put in the first phase of a crafting overhaul, and re-worked resource gathering and equipment upgrading, fixed several bugs (and added new ones).

The problem here is that most of these changes are incomplete. I can’t tell how the new crafting and upgrading changes are going to work because the systems for upgrading aren’t in. In general I like where they’re going, but what options will I have for upgrading the gear beyond that. Nothing I can make now is comparable to the harvesting gear that I’ve already made; and I wasn’t even done upgrading that.

The PvE combat in it’s current state is fun, but a bit tedious. Mobs are very strong so frequently you can only take a few hits, and the fights (if you’re doing well) can take a good bit because even with a pretty high damage rating these things can take a beating. (Keeping in mind that this is mainly me Duo-ing with ‘The Wife’ so there’s two of us hitting these things and the fights are still long.)

The exploration aspect is great. The caverns and layers of caverns hold interesting ruins to find (that were player created in game and selected by the devs through an event, some of them are very interesting and stumbling onto one as you go through a cavern is great. There’s also, of course, more mobs in the caverns than there are over land too so keep your weapons handy. They’ve also moved the higher ‘tier’ resources down into the caverns rather than across different tier islands so there are other reasons to go down into the dark depths.



Building is amazing and is definitely still the strength of the game. Some of the player created areas are absolutely incredible, and they just added linking and triggering to the game so you can link different props so that, for example, a door will open if someone enters the area in front of it. This is just the first layer of this type of thing that they’ve put in, but people have already built crazy things including a working digital clock with it. (Someone built a count down clock for New Years and one of the Devs created a firework display using links and triggers to light up the effects and explosions at the correct times).



Well, as I said, it’s being billed as a social/building MMO, so lets look at the social aspect. I’ll start with the basics – Chat. You have the standard text chat, I haven’t checked if custom channels are working across servers yet, but other than that issue basic chat, tells, group chat, guild chat, and officer chat, are there and seem pretty stable. Local is range limited so that’s something to keep in mind if you’re chatting with folks in local while running around. They’ve also put in game voice support in, but I haven’t tried it out yet.

Next is grouping. It’s in, and all things considered pretty well handled. Loot drops for everyone in the party, and I get the same type of loot solo that I do grouped so there doesn’t seem to be any realistic downside to being grouped. In fact since harvesting items are shared there’s a lot of reason TO group, as you can essentially multiply your gathering efforts if everyone is gathering. (For example, if I harvest 100 copper while grouped with the wife, I get 100 copper and my wife gets 100 copper as well.)

Guilds are in, and have their own guild ranks and chat channels, but currently that’s about the extent of guild functionality. They have plans for more (guild owned claims, guild banks and other things), but at this point I think that the ‘guild’ aspect of the game is a few notches down on the priority list, and that’s fine. A lot of the functionality I’d want for guilds are modifications on existing systems so shouldn’t be terribly complicated to add once they get the bigger systems where they want them and polished.

In summery I am really enjoying the game, the potential is even beyond what I saw back in the early stages of Alpha, but there’s still a lot of work to be done. This is not a world that’s going to be built in a day or a month, they have some of the biggest hurdles behind them I think though. I’ll be interested to see, now that they’re back from their much deserved break, what their plans are for the coming months and how quickly they can move through them. Currently this is looking to be probably one of the best ‘family’ MMOs out there, easy and fun for those gamer parents to bring their kids into and have fun exploring and building anything that their imaginations can come up with.

Tuesday, January 6, 2015

EQN: Landmark - Alpha

 [NOTE - This was originally meant to be posted almost a year ago (Mid Feb 2014) but was never actually finished. I am publishing it now with a few minor edits to clarify some things and will elaborate on things in another post where I discuss the more current version of closed beta that we are in at the moment. Please keep in mind that this was written during an early version of the Alpha and almost a year of development has passed since I originally wrote this. I am publishing this, in part, so that I can discuss things that may have changed in the course of that development. I will add a few notes in italics for clarity on a few points]

Well it's been about 6 months since I posted about EQNext and my thoughts on their big reveal at SOE Live. And I've been in EQNext Landmark's Alpha for almost 2 weeks (man it doesn't seem like it's been that long but I started downloading the client just after Midnight Feb 1st (2014) ... time flies when you're busy at work and having fun.)

Well ... SOE decided on Alpha day 01 to drop the NDA as it didn't fit with their 'open' method of game design I've posted a couple of screen caps on the facebook site (Scale of Pain Facebook) as well as links to their alpha (link is to the beta forums now, thought the alpha forums are archived there as well) forums which are open to read by anyone. As a result I've been gathering stuff for a article here on my impressions of the new and emerging game called Landmark.

First I want to start of with a bit of a 'What is Landmark' because that's a big question out there.

SOE says that Landmark is an "Online Social Building Game" ... but that's not completely accurate. Because it's not purely a building game. Building is certainly a focus as you can see by the shots of player built creations on the SOE landmark page but many people get the wrong idea when you simply say that it's a building game. It is NOT Minecraft creative mode where you have unlimited resources to build whatever you want.

It is a game that encourages exploration, resource gathering, and crafting and building ... including community building. While it's still in Alpha and many of the main systems are not yet in game I can say this, it's going to be a fun, and very very different idea of an MMO. The goal here is world that the players can make something, where a group, or guild, working together can focus their resources and talents to build something spectacular together. A game in which a dedicated community can come together and build a world around them in which they can tell their own story.

To a certain degree I disagree with this being called 'Everquest' because it isn't. Landmark does not take place on Norrath, nor does it take place at any specific time or even genre. It is being called Everquest Next: Landmark because it was developed as a result of the development of Everquest Next, that is to say it came about because when making EQN someone realized 'this is fun' and 'this could be a game itself.'

[NOTE - Apparently SOE agreed as the title of the game was officially changed to Landmark The Game shortly after I started writing this]

Next is the obvious - my impressions so far:

Simple - I am enjoying the game immensely. Even with only half or so of the content in, even in it's early stages I see promise. Servers are pretty stable, and aside from some database problems that the team sorted out in the first week things have been pretty smooth. There are bugs, and features that aren't in of course, but it's still early in the alpha stage so that's to be expected. They are applying several newer technologies to the game, and taking others that haven't really been used this way before. (One of the biggest problems of week one wasn't discovered until alpha started because they hadn't been using multiple servers until that point.)

Through all the trouble of the start of Alpha and the problems that have popped up here and there, the Dev team has done a great job communicating what they're working on and why things are happening. Posts on the forums are frequent, and the team is very active on Twitter. Tweeting members of the team often gets a response and by and large the testers have been a pretty good group looking for and reporting problems, giving feedback and suggestions, and pointing out potential flaws.

Now on to some of the complaints I've seen -

No other races - Yes, I would like to see them put in races other than Human, but at this stage, races don't matter, and in the end I don't think that should be a focus for Landmark. I would like to see them put in illusions or 'costumes' so that we as players could choose to look like different fantasy races or aliens, etc to help us build and populate that world or section of the world where we tell our story, but in terms of character creation I don't think different races should be a priority for the team.

Too much grind - way too early to judge something like that. Many systems aren't in and much of what IS in, is in a temporary state to jump start testing. Numbers and required resources are something that will likely be tuned through alpha and into late beta as new things are added and their effects on the system are evaluated. Having been through a few alphas and betas in the past this is normal.

(also a note on the 'grind' from my perspective at least - the 'grind' is a misplaced focus on the part of the player. That is to say that it means that the player has chosen to focus on 'getting X' instead of 'having fun' either due to the belief that 'X' is needed to have fun, or just because of the player's own personality. As a result any repetitive task that needs to be accomplished becomes a 'grind' that is keeping them from getting 'X' ... players that focus on things like 'having fun with some friends' or 'exploring to look for 'Y' often find themselves in possession of 'X' without having really thought about the 'grind' that it took to get it.)

Saturday, August 14, 2010

Garden of EVE

Readers from the Path of Bones may remember a previous mention of a game called EVE Online, and I suspect that anyone that has surfed the net, particularly game related sites, has probably seen their banner and sidebar adds.

My wife and I first encountered EVE Online shortly before it's May 2003 launch as beta testers. At the time we felt it was a game with potential, but too many bugs and too steep of a learning curve to be enjoyable. The game also prominently featured an open PvP focus, and that did not appeal to us at the time. (My personal opinion of open PvP has changed over the years, and now I believe that, properly handled, it can be a great way to add depth and realism in MMOs.)

But let me back up for a moment for those that don't know what EVE Online is about. Personally I consider EVE to be one of the most innovative MMOs to date, with many elements that I would love to see developing MMOs consider adding to their feature list. The concept is simple enough - your character is a pod pilot, a starship pilot above and beyond a simple commander. Your neural interface to your pod, and thus your entire ship, gives you a serious edge to normal starship captains (NPCs), and you're looking to make your mark on the big bad universe through combat, trade, manufacturing, or some combination there of. But within that basic simplicity is the full complexity of the universe ... there is a reason that CCP hired a real economist to manage and report on the in game economy of EVE.

The depth and complexity of the game, however, nearly killed it before it had a chance to blossom. Between the bugs that are inherent with a system that complex and a learning curve that, to a new player, appeared to be a sheer cliff with no hand holds in sight the game nearly didn't retain enough players to survive launch. The developers stuck to their guns, fixing bugs, improving the new player tutorial, and launching an internet ad campaign that was nothing short of viral. Over the 7 years that the game has been 'live' they have managed to build one of the most successful MMOs to date with their single server hosting more than 40, 000 players online simultaneously at peak times. (I know I've seen over 44,000, I believe they've had 46 or 47,000 ... and in June of this year they broke their previous record with 60,543 concurrent accounts logged in.)

Roughly 3 years ago my wife and I were looking for something different and decided to give EVE a try to see what had changed in the 4 years since the beta. What we found was a game that we not only enjoyed immensely but one that has certainly captured a place in our top MMOs. While we have departed from the game a few times, we have come back to it again fairly regularly.

So what brings us back? Speaking for myself, of course, it's hard to say exactly. It's a number of things really, the expansive, thriving, player driven economy, the skill based character advancement, and the variety of things available to a player; mission running, mining, PvP, or even just trading ... and almost all of it is available to all players of any skill level. (Though admittedly a player looking to carve out a place for himself out in the lawless frontier of 0.0 space is either going to need serious Corporation (guild/clan) support, a large number of skill points, or probably both.)

EVE, however, is a game that is well suited to a goal oriented player. The problem for a new player can be the sheer number of goals available to pursue, but in EVE given time and effort just about any goal is achievable. Time is, of course, one of the keys, even more so in EVE because skill advancement is based on real time; not played time ... real time. If a skill lists the training time as 4 days 12 hours when you start training, it will finish in 4 day and 12 hours online or offline, unless you interrupt it, or change your stats in a way that decreases the time requirement. This is great for a casual player because it means that as long as you have a skill in training it doesn't matter if you can only play an hour every other day that 30 day training plan will take 30 days to train (provided that you stay on top of the training to always have that next skill lined up and ready to go when it is time.)

Where the casual player can fall behind is, of course, money, but this is something that is easier for the player to equalize with friends than it can be in other MMOs where they can't give you XP to help you level. In EVE the casual player can either have the support of friends that are playing to help him, or it is also possible to purchase game currency indirectly in game by buying PLEX (an in game item that represents 30 days of game time) and selling the PLEX for in game currency. This also means that those players that have the means of generating enough ISK (in game currency) can basically play the game for free by buying their game time through PLEX in game.

In fact the community itself has developed a thriving economy outside of the game as well with several EVE related website hosting companies and other service type providers accepting ISK in exchange for their services.

The game, of course, does have it's flaws, from occasional glitches and bugs to griefers and pirates. Some people find it repetitive and cumbersome; though I believe that the latter complaints are more a result of player focus and perspective ... I mean when you break it down, life is repetitive - you get up in the morning, go to work, do the same basic things at work all day, come home, and most people have a daily or weekly routine that takes up much of the rest of their waking hours.

Many players also complain about a disconnect between the player and character due to the 'disembodied' nature of the game. That is to say that, at this point in the game, you can not leave your ship; you never see your character except for a portrait that you make at character creation. Likewise you can not customize the appearance of your ship. And other players consider the game a giant spreadsheet with a sci-fi user interface.

Certainly it's not a game for everyone, the PvP element alone will turn a lot of people off. For those fans of space trading games in the vein of Elite, Wing Commander: Privateer, or the X series the game offers a deep universe with some 7000+ systems, a manufacturing system that allows players to make everything from ammunition to largest capital ships in the game. For players that love PvP EVE offers full FFA open PvP (with some restrictions) and the opportunity to carve out their own section of frontier space and defend it against all opponents. For those that want a mix there's mission running, mining and exploration for the PvEers, and for those that want some PvP but not the full hard core of the frontier there's 'low sec' pirate hunting or Militia faction warfare.

If you do give it a try do remember that the universe is a very big and very unforgiving place, while there are certainly plenty of players out there willing to help a new player learn the ropes (EVE University for example) there are also plenty of sharks looking for fresh meat. Also remember, reputation can have an impact, while there are restrictions EVE is essentially FFA PvP (anyone can attack you at anytime) and even though most of the time 'empire' or 'high sec' is pretty safe, it is usually not a good idea to move highly valuable cargo in small unprotected ships: Link.

Friday, April 9, 2010

Questing or Camping

In MMOs one of the primary complaints has always been the 'grind' ... that is to say the repetitive completion of an action in order to gain the XP needed in order to gain the next level and advance your characters skills/abilities/power.

First of all I have always said, and continue to hold that the 'grind' is mental and is therefor never going to be eliminated. It is a state of mind rather than a function of any specific game mechanic. That is to say that all games (and life in general for that matter) have repetition, it is up to the player whether that repetition is a 'grind' or not.

The mental aspect of the 'grind', however, isn't what I intended to write about today.

As I've played MMOs over the years I've seen games move from the 'camp' based grind to the 'quest' based grind ... both have their advantages and their problems.

The 'camp' grind - This is the main 'grind' in many of the older MMOs such as Everquest where the majority of a characters experience was earned through defeating NPC foes. This lead to players finding NPC concentrations and setting up 'camps' pulling and killing the NPCs for the experience. Larger or stronger groups of players could, thus, lay claim to larger or stronger 'camps' in order to receive greater experience.

The primary disadvantages to the 'camp' style of grinding in the older MMOs were that 'good' camping areas became known and were often crowded or claimed by other players. It's static nature also contributed significantly to the 'grind' mentality as players frequently sat in an area for days or weeks worth of play time camping in a given area or zone. (20 levels or so fear kiting in the Overthere to name a personal experience)

The advantages, however, are more subtle and often over looked both by players and by designers. One of these is socializing - the ability to sit and chat while 'camping' in a given area. Socially there is also an advantage in creating multiple areas in which people can meet up and gather; that is to say that people will tend to go to the known camping areas, often logging out in the area as well, and as a result there will be a ready 'pool' of people with the same goal to form groups with.

This brings us to the 'quest' grind - Newer MMOs, in an attempt to 'eliminate the grind' have, of course, simply replaced it with another form of grinding. Basically they weighted the experience gain heavily toward quest completion, so hours of killing mobs was replaced with hours of running around completing quests. Tougher quests require stronger groups and give better rewards and experience.

The down sides to the 'quest' model are primarily travel and decreased socialization. Travel in that you spend time going to a quest hub, getting the quests, going to the quest areas, completing the quests and returning to the hub to turn in the quests and get follow-ups or new quests. The decrease in socialization is due both to people socializing less while traveling, and the complications it creates in group formation.

That is to say that even if you are at a quest hub you need to find a group, ideally, that is on the same quests as you, otherwise either you are repeating quests at minimal benefit to yourself to get others up to where you are, or others are repeating quests to catch you up to them. As a result some players will be unwilling to admit anyone into their groups if they aren't currently on certain quests.

The advantages are that it is a more active method of playing and sometimes can be easier to see progress as quest goals get checked off and experience is usually gained in large chunks at once. It keeps people moving and engages them more with the world around them and its lore.

Presently most games are all one way or the other ... that is to say that either questing experience gain so over powers camping experience that it is pointless to camp, or questing experience is virtually irrelevant and quests are only done for loot rewards or flavor by players interested in those things.

In many ways I think that this is a mistake. I like both systems, though I have to admit that in many ways I prefer the 'camp' system, and would like to see these two systems be able to live more in harmony than has yet been achieved.

Yes, in most 'quest' based systems you can choose to 'camp' in a traditional sense. You will still earn experience of course, but the problem is that you are essentially putting your character advancement on hold because the experience for killing NPCs is so anemic. In a single player game this wouldn't be an issue, but in a game where you end up dragging down your friends or guild as a result of your preferences it creates stress and tension if you choose to 'buck the game design.'

One of the 'problems' in balancing the two systems and having them work in harmony is the inherent boost that the 'quest' grind naturally gets ... that is to say that as you do the quest you get experience for killing the NPCs as needed for the quest, and then when you complete and turn in the quest you get an additional chunk of experience as a reward. So 'balancing' the two paths is somewhat of a developer's nightmare; too much of an experience boost from the turn in and we're essentially back to a pure quest grind system punishing those that choose not to quest, not enough and then the travel time and other such factors can quickly make questing too inefficient a path for leveling.

Of all the MMOGs I've played over the years, however, I find that I still, in many ways, prefer the 'camp' based grind of the original EverQuest. It may purely be nostalgia related as EQ was my first ever MMO, but actually I think it is because of the freedom it offers. I can still go and work on quests, and while it may mean putting my character's level advancement on hold for a bit while I do, the quests themselves offer their own rewards for completing them. It allows me to take a break from 'the grind' and still accomplish something, and, since quests themselves have their own advantages, it can be just as fun helping a friend finish a quest as it is gaining a new level.

On the other hand, in a 'quest' based system I find that since questing becomes the 'norm' in terms of gaining experience and levels the sense of accomplishment is really lost and as a result there is no satisfaction in the act of completing the quest itself. Psychologically there becomes nothing else to the game except earning the next level, or getting the next piece of gear and as a result it actually becomes more of a grind than camping ever really seemed to be.